Metamorphosis Spring 2014

Obedience, Resistance, and Legible Martyrdoms: Narratives of Persecution in Reformation England

Annie Morphew
Faculty Mentor: Dr. Jennifer Deane
University of Minnesota, Morris

Abstract

Historians have long paid attention to the crucial role played by Tudor and Stuart monarchs in determining and enforcing religious policy during the English Reformation. However, both Catholic and Protestant polemicists and victims of persecution also played decisive roles as arbiters of their own places within the complex matrix of English religious and political affiliation. Defining their relationship to legitimate sources of authority was a key strategy of both Catholics and Protestants. Of course, the English reformers and their Catholic contemporaries do not have a monopoly on the experience of negotiating with political authority. For example, Protestants in Germany, Switzerland, and France also engaged in claiming and defining more or less advantageous relationships to political powers and, in some cases, even developing their own structures of political authority. What makes the English Reformation unique is the interplay of volatile dynastic policy driven by particularly forceful personalities and coalescing confessional groups. The strains imposed by this context on both Catholics and Protestants are particularly evident in persecution narratives. Narratives of persecution, and critiques of them, reveal the high stakes and unique contours of the English Reformation landscape. Central to these narratives are a quest for legitimacy and legibility as true martyrs and victims of religious persecution. The success or failure of a narrative depends on the text’s depiction of the persecuted as obedient subjects of legitimate political authority and orderly participants in English society; at the same time, however, authors redefine the locus of legitimate authority and provide subtle commentary on Reformation policy.

❐ PDF

Keywords: Catholicism, Protestantism, English Reformation, England, religion

Blurred Lines
Multifaceted Truths Veiled in the Works and Life of Oscar Wilde

Danica Leninsky
Faculty Mentor: Dr. Chris Foss
University of Mary Washington

Abstract

Aphorisms, lying, and faulty logic abound in the works and life of Oscar Wilde. Characters who embrace these tactics, as Wilde does, possess a multifaceted sense of truth, giving them the ability to find truth beneath the façade of contradictions and develop a sense of individualism. People who insist upon thinking in a binary, either/or mindset, thus seeking fundamental truths, are unable to garner truth from Wilde's seemingly contradictory phrasing and reasoning. Drawing on a range of Wilde’s work from essays like “The Critic as Artist” and “The Portrait of Mr. W. H.” to Wilde’s society plays and The Picture of Dorian Gray, I demonstrate that while Wilde and his characters may seem unknowable through the haze of aphorisms and faulty logic, it is only through these contradictions that they can be truly understood. Additionally, I highlight how Wilde’s use of aphorisms during his infamous libel trials reveal the binary nature of the judicial system and of society as a whole at that time. To appreciate the depth of Wilde, one must accept that there are always multifaceted truths and alternate interpretations, something that many of his characters and contemporaries fail to do.

❐ PDF

Keywords: Oscar Wilde, aphorisms, literature

Life on the Fence
The Hidden Power of the “Tragic Mulatto”

Halan DeBoise
Faculty Mentor: Rebecca Clausen
Fort Lewis College

Abstract

 The Mulatto by Seymour G. Link
Because my Mother thought
That a black sin
Was white if it was brought
In a White skin,

Because my father brought
At cost of pride
The lusthead that he sought
From a black bride

The god’s bestow on me
A life of hate-
A white man’s gift to see
A nigger’s fate

O, god who gave me sight
To see my lack-Dreams of a bitter white
And soul of black

Must I forever be
Slurred of two races?
Must I forever see
Kin of two faces? (Link 1929)

❐ PDF

Keywords: poetry, Seymour G. Link, literature, poetry analysis

Gender and Sexuality in College Hook-Up Culture
How Confession Websites Challenge (and Uphold) Oppressive Ideologies

Kelly Avant
Faculty Mentor: Gina Velasco
Fort Lewis College

Abstract

In this project is an interpretation of how the ideas of gender performativity and compulsory heterosexuality can inform our understanding of college hook-up culture. The focus is on the following questions: How do we use these hetero-gendered roles to make meaning of our experiences in hook-up culture? To what extent does the dominance of this script limit our ability to imagine alternatives to the hook-up? Through this analysis one can begin to address the problematic realities visible in hook-up culture, as well as recognizing the increased agency provided through these new social scripts. This project is an analysis of posts from a confessions website allowing students to write anonymously about their experiences within hook-up culture. These websites are a previously untapped academic resource calling for further investigation. Posts describing sexual encounters are coded for terms and concepts relating directly to gender, heterosexuality and the dominance of the hook-up script. Data is organized into groups reflecting the three most prevalent types of relationship referenced: long- term monogamous partners, long-term non-monogamous partners, and short-term non- monogamous partners. These encounters provide a wide diversity of experiences both challenging and upholding hegemonic ideologies of gender and sexuality. The hook-up script has in many ways increased sexual agency, but its dominance veils alternative scripts, severely limiting the choices of participants.

❐ PDF

Keywords: gender, sexuality, compulsory heterosexuality, Hook-Up Culture, confession websites

Inside the Hidden House of Healing
Intentionality and Liminality at a Domestic Violence Shelter

Kenton Bell
Faculty Mentor: Dr. Heidi Kelley
University of North Carolina Asheville

Abstract

Helpmate, a domestic violence agency in Asheville, NC, operates a secure shelter that is a home and a fortress, created by professional and volunteer advocates to assist women and children in regaining their agency through intentionality by moving past the role of victim into the role of survivor. By using the methodologies of cultural anthropology, a narrative will emerge from the visual representations of intentionality throughout the shelter. This ethnography depicts the vibrant and mundane details of a liminal space that is equal parts counseling center, office building, children’s playground, and family room—concealed behind barricades and security cameras. By giving voice to the lives of women and children affected by violence and the advocates that serve them, light can penetrate the shadows to reveal a visual narrative of healing, community, and intentionality.

❐ PDF

Keywords: domestic violence shelter, intentionality, liminality, domestic violence

The Critical Faith
A Paper Concerning Kant's Belief in God

L. F. Braley
Faculty Mentor: Nicholas Germana
Keene State College

Abstract

This paper examines the evolution of Kant's thinking about God to try to come to a better understanding of exactly what he believed. By examining relevant primary and secondary sources, the paper seeks to give an account of a unity in Kant's personal belief in a God even alongside his changing philosophical views on the matter. Upon a careful elucidation of his principle works which refer to God, it becomes clear that liberating faith from the charge of being irrational was among Kant's highest priorities throughout his career. Kant's “Copernican revolution” opened the door for rational theism which traditional Enlightenment philosophy did not, a door through which Kant eagerly stepped.

❐ PDF

Keywords: philosophy, Immanuel Kant, theism, faith

Is College Worth the Cost
A Data-Driven Analysis of the Student Loan Bubble

Marty Rogachefsky
Faculty Mentor: Dr. Steve Greenlaw and Dr. Leonie Stone
SUNY College at Geneseo

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to examine the possibility of a student loan bubble and analyze micro and macroeconomic remedies and policies that can be undertaken in such a bubble exists. In light of record amounts of student loan debt (recently passing the one trillion dollar mark), there has been much concern as to whether the value of a college education is worth the costs in tuition and interest paid on loans. If the actual value of a college education is much lower than the current value, then this has potential to be an asset-price bubble.

The paper begins by defining a bubble as an asymmetric deviation of the market price of an asset from its fundamental value over a period of several months or years, that inevitably leads to a significant reverse correction as seen by a fall in prices. The paper then uses data to calculate the value of college via an earnings differential between high school and college graduates and comparing it to the net cost of college to calculate a cost-earnings ratio. It then examine several other indicators, including cost-earnings ratio by degree, private-public education enrollment, and a potential bubble in for-profit colleges. It concludes that there is little evidence to support a bubble in student loans.

❐ PDF

Keywords: student loans, college, university, education

A Time and Place for Premarital Desire
Positive Uses of Lust in Edmund Spenser's The Faerie Queene

Rachel Balzar
Faculty Mentor: Dr. Julie Eckerle
University of Minnesota, Morris

Abstract

Lust plays a large role in Edmund Spenser’s famous 1590 poem The Faerie Queene- this much Early Modern scholars can agree on. Surrounding the purpose lust serves in this didactic tale, however, there is a good deal of contention. Some academics argue that Spenser uses his lurid descriptions of lust to reveal to readers their own sinful preferences. Others claim that Spenser uses lust simply to attract an audience. The list of differing interpretations of the text goes on. But one overarching theme can be seen in all of these unique analyses of lust: each operates on the assumption that Spenser intended lust to be an entirely wicked force in his romance. In my essay, I seek to challenge this assumption. I believe that in order to create more nuanced theories regarding desire in Spenser’s poem, it is necessary to move beyond the tendency to take the evil of lust as a given. Thus, in my own research, I have attempted to keep an open mind regarding the nature of desire in The Faerie Queene. Through close analysis of the tale’s wealthy heroes, who channel their sexual energies toward a higher cause, I assert that Spenser proposes that lust can have a positive use when experienced by members of the upper-class. This means of understanding Spenser’s poem is innovative and unique, but it also proves to be illuminating.

❐ PDF

Keywords: Edmund Spenser, The Faerie Queene, literature, lust

From Bakhtin to Skyrim
An Examination of Chronotopes, Genre, and the Chivalric Romance

Sean Fischer
Faculty Mentor: Dr. Ken Tiller, UVA Wise
SUNY College at Geneseo

Abstract

The concept of genres is one that has evolved little since Aristotle wrote on the matter in his Poetics. As a result, critics have generally repeated the same song and dance, to the same ends, when dealing with genres and generic analysis of texts. For this reason, I have researched different ways of grouping texts together, with a particular focus on Structuralist theories of genre. These theories, especially those posited by Tzvetan Todorv and Thomas Winner, emphasize the use of formalist techniques as organizing principles for genres, instead of more general concepts such as theme, motif, or characterization. The second half of my research investigated particularly interesting and impactful techniques to organize genres around. The technique that stood out the most to me was Mikhail Bakhtin’s chronotope, which relates the temporal and spatial relationships in a text. The final aspect of my research involved combining the particular Structuralist genre theories with Bakhtin’s theory on the chronotope, in order to come up with a new, more interesting definition for genre. I tested this definition by analyzing the genre of Chivalric Romance. In particular, I close read The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, and demonstrated the ways in which it fit into the Chivalric Romance tradition. This result challenges traditional assumptions about the Romance genre, and leads to several interesting issues in cultural studies. Specifically, the issue of shared value systems between cultures that traditionally are thought of being dissimilar arises.

❐ PDF

Keywords: chivalric romance, romance genre, literature, Skyrim

High Intensity Interval Training as Means to Reduce Symptoms of Metabolic Syndrome

Veniece Fagerlin
Faculty Mentor: Carrie Meyer
Fort Lewis College

Abstract

In 2006, 34% of adults in America met the criteria for Metabolic Syndrome (MetSyn), with men and women 40-59 years of age having triple the chance of meeting the criteria than younger adults (Ervin, 2009).

Purpose - The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of High Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) on the symptoms of MetSyn in women 40-65 years of age.

Methods - Volunteers were solicited from Durango, CO and surrounding communities for participation in this study. Participants were randomly assigned to a study group (SG)(n=11) or control (CG)(n=11). All participants were measured for waist circumference (WC), blood pressure (BP), triglycerides (TG), high-density lipoproteins (HDL), and fasting glucose (FG). The SG exercised with body weight only four times a week for six weeks. Each session included three sets using the same exercises but with intensity increasing by speed of execution. The CG maintained their lifestyle and attended measuring sessions.

Results - Systolic (SBP) and diastolic (DBP) blood pressure did not statistically improve (p=0.121 and p=0.316 respectively). FG (p=0.784) and HDL (p=0.085) measures did not improve. Waist circumference did not significantly improve (p=0.148) yet there was improvement in the SG means. TG showed significant improvement (p=0.023).

Conclusion - Despite the change in TG as a result of this six-week study, HIIT did not significantly reduce all the symptoms of MetSyn in women 40-65 years of age.

❐ PDF

Keywords: High Intensity Interval Training, metabolism, metabolic syndrome, blood pressure

Affordance Theory and Fitts’s Law in UI Design for Web-based Survey

Yang Li
Faculty Mentor: Dr. Mark Cohen
Truman State University

Abstract

Web surveys have advantages over their paper counterparts in aspects such as lower marginal costs, flexible data management, reporting systems, and higher incidence rates. These advantages contribute to the growth of web surveys used in business, research, and other areas. However, as web surveys have become increasingly popular, respondents are more likely to experience survey fatigue. When survey fatigue occurs the quality of their answers deteriorate, and consequently the respondents lose patience and become increasingly prone to producing “straight-line” answers. Among many factors, obtrusive user interface design is an issue that can be easily improved by applying good user interface design principles.

This research studies the application of Gibson’s affordance theory and Fitts’s Law in web interface design, and examines whether they will improve the effectiveness and result quality of web surveys. Controlled experiments are set up to compare the interface alternatives in the following aspects: user response time, response quality, and user preference of either interface.

The research results indicate that there is an improvement in response time and response quality when the web survey interface adopts the Fitts’s Law and offers users appropriate affordances. In addition, the results also reveal that users might not be aware of the benefits of web form interfaces with better affordances over traditional ones without using them; however, most users can identify the benefits once they have used the interfaces with better affordances.

❐ PDF

Keywords: web surveys, Fitts’s Law, computer science, user interface design